OSHA Says No to Post-Accident Drug Testing

There has been a buzz in the drug testing industry regarding OSHA and potential prohibitions on post-accident drug testing. Employers and drug testing industry professionals alike have asked OSHA for further clarification of the new rulemaking which goes into effect August 10. 2016.

The Occupational Safety and Health Act (OHSA) as of August 10, 2016 will begin enforcing its new regulation requiring employers to have a “reasonable procedure” for employees to report work-related injuries and illnesses, and not to discriminate or retaliate against employees who report such injuries or illnesses.  OSHA wants to make sure employees feel safe about reporting workplace injury or illness.

OSHA has addressed post-accident drug testing in this regulation with a concern about an employer’s motivation in implementing post-accident drug testing. If OSHA determines that the intent of an employer’s post-accident policy is to deter or discourage the reporting of work-related injuries or illnesses, then OSHA is likely to issue a citation seeking to eliminate an employer’s continued use of such a policy.

Don’t panic, employers are still able to conduct post-accident drug testing, but company policies must be reviewed.  The OSHA rule does not prohibit drug testing of employees. It only prohibits employers from using drug testing, or the threat of drug testing, as a form of retaliation against employees who report injuries or illnesses. If an employer conducts drug testing to comply with the requirements of a state or federal law or regulation, the employer’s motive would not be retaliatory and this rule would not prohibit such testing.

OSHA says in the final rule that employer policies should limit post-incident testing to situations in which employee substance use is likely to have contributed to the incident, and used when the drug test can accurately identify the impairment caused by drug use.  The impairment statement from OSHA is a point of concern for both employers and the drug testing industry as there are currently no scientific methodologies to detect impairment from illegal drug use.  Perhaps a solution is to use lab-based oral fluid drug testing for post-accident situations because the oral fluid testing detects very recent drug use.

Our guidance for employers is to carefully review the language and intent of provisions in drug-free workplace programs.  Blanket post-accident testing policy statements should be removed.  Policies should be tightened to tie referrals for post-accident testing to situations where it appears an employee caused or contributed to the accident.

For example, it would likely not be reasonable to drug-test an employee who reports a bee sting, a repetitive strain injury, or an injury caused by a lack of machine guarding or a machine or tool malfunction.  Such a policy is likely only to deter accident reporting.

OSHA cannot prohibit post accident drug testing, but if they determine a policy or practice restricts an employer’s obligation to ensure that employees report work-related injuries and illnesses; this is where there could be a problem with OSHA.

Post-accident drug and alcohol testing should also be combined with a full investigation of each and every workplace accident. Employers should follow the tips below:

Have a Written and Promulgated Drug-Testing Policy.

The policy should contain a statement that all employees are subject to drug testing and that a refusal to take a drug screen will result in a presumption that the test would have been positive. Furthermore, the drug policy should be signed by the employee and be universally enforced. If the policy is not enforced, the claimant can argue that no policy exists.  Post-accident testing requirements should be clearly explained.

Training & Education

Your drug free workplace program must have a training and education component. Employees and supervisors must know the policy, the consequences of violating the policy and the harmful effects of drugs/alcohol in the workplace. Supervisors must be able to make decisions for reasonable suspicion testing and must know the company policy inside and out.

Always Follow the Company Policy in Determining Post Accident Testing

If there situation aligns with the company policy for post-accident testing, arrange for the testing immediately to occur after any necessary medical attention.  Consider lab based oral fluid testing to detect recent drug use.

Take a Written Statement From an Injured Employee After an Accident.

The statement should ask specifically whether the employee had consumed any alcohol within 24 hours of the accident or any non-prescribed controlled substances, including cocaine or marijuana, within 30 days of the accident. Have the employee sign the statement.

Take Written Statements of Co-workers.

If you suspect drug use by the injured employee, ask the co-employees whether they noticed any unusual behavior. Never discuss the results of any drug tests with the injured worker’s co-employees.

Have Drug Tests Collected and Performed by a Reputable Vendor.

A medical drug test performed for treating a patient is different from an employment drug test. The employment drug test procedure must follow company policy, Federal and/State law and specifically quantifies the drug and alcohol levels. Furthermore, the testing entity should follow the Federal guidelines the collection and testing procedures.

Approve Emergency Care for an Injured Employee

The injured employee will be entitled to reasonable emergency medical care until he is stabilized or discharged.

Do Not Encourage the Use of Alcohol.

Have a written policy against using alcohol, even in work- related activities.

OSHA Says No to Post-Accident Drug Testing
More Posts